Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa vs Montauk Yacht Club
Two of Montauk, New York's best properties - rates, honest differences, and what sets them apart.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
An iconic oceanfront resort perched directly on the dramatic bluffs of Montauk.
Montauk Yacht Club
A classic waterfront sanctuary tucked along Star Island on Lake Montauk.
Which one should you book?
Choose Gurney's Montauk for direct Atlantic Ocean surf, private beach club scene, and seawater wellness; choose Montauk Yacht Club for calm harborfront marina lifestyle, boating, paddleboarding, and family resort recreation on Lake Montauk.
- ✓2,000 feet of direct ocean beachfront with crashing Atlantic waves
- ✓Iconic Seawater Spa and elevated oceanfront fine dining at Scarpetta Beach
- ✓High-energy Hamptons summer scene and upscale beach lounge atmosphere
- ✓Panoramic clifftop sunset and sunrise views over the open ocean
- ✓Protected waterfront estate on Lake Montauk with a 200-slip private marina
- ✓Calm, flat-water activities: private boat charters, sailing, paddleboarding, and kayaking
- ✓Extensive family amenities including tennis and pickleball courts, heated pools, and lawns
- ✓Recently transformed Ralph Lauren-inspired coastal nautical design by Proper Hospitality
Key Trade-offs at a Glance
What Sets Them Apart
The details that matter at this level.
Gurney's is on the open Atlantic Ocean; Montauk Yacht Club is on protected Lake Montauk harbor.
Gurney's is centered on beach club lounging and spa; MYC is centered on boating, sailing, and racquet sports.
Gurney's is glamorous and social; MYC is relaxed, nautical, and family-friendly.
12-Month Nightly Rate Comparison
Average nightly base rates across the calendar year. Click or hover any month to compare.
The Bottom Line
Choose Gurney's Montauk for direct Atlantic Ocean surf, private beach club scene, and seawater wellness; choose Montauk Yacht Club for calm harborfront marina lifestyle, boating, paddleboarding, and family resort recreation on Lake Montauk.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa starts from $480/night; Montauk Yacht Club from $350/night. Both are available through Wildist at the same rate as booking direct - with VIP perks, room upgrades, and dedicated advisor support included.
Ready to Book? We'll Handle the Rest.
Both Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa and Montauk Yacht Club are available through Wildist at the same rate as booking direct — with exclusive VIP perks added at no extra cost.