WildistHotels
Montauk, New York · Head-to-Head Comparison

Montauk Yacht Club vs Marram Montauk

Two of Montauk, New York's best properties - rates, honest differences, and what sets them apart.

Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk, New York
From
$350/nt
Lake & Ocean Harbor

Montauk Yacht Club

A classic waterfront sanctuary tucked along Star Island on Lake Montauk.

Full Guide
Marram Montauk
Montauk, New York
From
$380/nt
Ocean Dunes

Marram Montauk

A barefoot-luxury oceanfront haven grounded in natural cedar, sea oats, and surf culture.

Full Guide
🧭 How to Choose

Which one should you book?

Choose Montauk Yacht Club for a full-service marina resort with padel, pools, and boat slips; choose Marram for barefoot luxury directly on the ocean surf dunes with surf lessons and yoga.

Book Montauk Yacht Club if you want:
  • ✓Private marina with 200+ boat slips and Lake Montauk water sports
  • ✓Full resort amenities with padel courts, tennis, and multiple pools
  • ✓Ocean and harbor cruiser shuttles and seaside fire pits
Book Marram Montauk if you want:
  • ✓Directly on the Atlantic ocean beach and famed Terrace surf break
  • ✓Minimalist, barefoot luxury design with cedar wood and neutral linen tones
  • ✓Daily morning yoga on the ocean deck and surf coaching with local pros
Side-by-Side Comparison

Key Trade-offs at a Glance

Feature
Montauk Yacht Club
Marram Montauk
Starting Rate
$350/nt
$380/nt
Peak Season
$1,300+/nt
$1,750+/nt
Setting & Style
Lake & Ocean Harbor
Ocean Dunes
Wildist Perks
Breakfast, Credits & Upgrades
Direct Booking Support
Key Differences

What Sets Them Apart

The details that matter at this level.

Location

Yacht Club is on Lake Montauk on the bay side; Marram is directly on the oceanfront beach.

Vibe

Yacht Club is lively, nautical, and active; Marram is quiet, barefoot, and surf-aesthetic.

Beach

Yacht Club uses harbor shuttles to ocean beaches; Marram steps directly onto the sand.

Pricing Dynamics

12-Month Nightly Rate Comparison

Average nightly base rates across the calendar year. Click or hover any month to compare.

Montauk Yacht Club
Marram Montauk
Selected Timeframe
August
Montauk Yacht Club
$1,300/nt
Marram Montauk
$1,750/nt
$400
$900
$1.3k
$1.8k
January
Montauk Yacht Club: $350
Marram Montauk: $380
Jan
February
Montauk Yacht Club: $350
Marram Montauk: $380
Feb
March
Montauk Yacht Club: $390
Marram Montauk: $420
Mar
April
Montauk Yacht Club: $450
Marram Montauk: $520
Apr
May
Montauk Yacht Club: $650
Marram Montauk: $780
May
June
Montauk Yacht Club: $950
Marram Montauk: $1,200
Jun
July
Montauk Yacht Club: $1,250
Marram Montauk: $1,650
Jul
August
Montauk Yacht Club: $1,300
Marram Montauk: $1,750
Aug
September
Montauk Yacht Club: $850
Marram Montauk: $1,100
Sep
October
Montauk Yacht Club: $550
Marram Montauk: $650
Oct
November
Montauk Yacht Club: $420
Marram Montauk: $460
Nov
December
Montauk Yacht Club: $380
Marram Montauk: $410
Dec
Final Takeaway

The Bottom Line

Choose Montauk Yacht Club for a full-service marina resort with padel, pools, and boat slips; choose Marram for barefoot luxury directly on the ocean surf dunes with surf lessons and yoga.

Montauk Yacht Club starts from $350/night; Marram Montauk from $380/night. Both are available through Wildist at the same rate as booking direct - with VIP perks, room upgrades, and dedicated advisor support included.

Same Rate. More Perks.

Ready to Book? We'll Handle the Rest.

Both Montauk Yacht Club and Marram Montauk are available through Wildist at the same rate as booking direct — with exclusive VIP perks added at no extra cost.